While evidence exists that Earth showed signs of a general cooling trend over the 4,000 years preceding the Industrial Revolution, other data suggest the planet had been getting warmer over that same time period. Ellie Broadman, a researcher in the University of Arizona Tree Ring Lab who recently co-authored a review of paleoclimate temperatures, estimates a mild cooling trend driven by "slight variations in the Earth's orbit around the sun" began about 6,500 years ago.